I have a confession. I usually call preaching by another name. I refer to it by the odd and bulkier two-word phrase sermon communication. At best, this word choice raises an eyebrow and a follow-up question from pastors. At worst, the term creates defensiveness, misconceptions, and even distance between some clergy and me. Oh, the power of words!
This past semester I witnessed this power at work when I invited a guest speaker to my Intercultural Communication class. The students were a highly engaged group on whom I could depend for lively dialogue. I bragged to the speaker about these eager learners, promising highly responsive listeners as the reward for donating his time and energy. The speaker had been asked to discuss language and race, and he titled his talk “The N Word.” As this passionate black man and his white colleague pulled up their first slide displaying the title of their session, the room fell silent. Not just hushed, with the usual background noise of laptop keyboard clicks and students shifting in their seats, but completely and utterly quiet.
During the presentation, this experienced speaker and his colleague had us hear “the word” again and again—voiced by comedians, rappers, white supremacists, and unidentifiable others. Questions from the speakers followed: Do you use this word? How do you use it? Have you heard it used? How does the history of the word affect the way it is used? Does the use of this word in certain contexts affect its use in broader culture? Who can use this word? When can they use it? How could meaning related to this word change over time?
The pin-dropping pauses lengthened after each question was asked. If you know northeastern Wisconsin, you may be able to guess that, as is sometimes possible in this region, the speaker was the only African American in the room. Finally, one young woman said, “That is a bad word that I was taught never to say.” Then someone else added, “But people do say it. You know, they don’t mean it in a bad way—um, usually . . .” A few other brave learners commented politely. After the presentation, students wrote about the experience, and nearly all said they were struck by their own unusual silence. One student noted, “That word has so much power. It shut us all up. Nothing has ever done that before.” And a senior communication major who had sat stone-faced and unflinching throughout the class session scribbled, “I will never forget this presentation. I had no idea what a word could do.”
You probably already accept that word choice matters. Some words are even considered so hateful and simply “wrong” that their use has been challenged in the U.S. Supreme Court, in spite of this country’s firm legal and cultural commitment to freedom of speech. “Pastor” Fred Phelps (notice how uncomfortable I am giving him that title) leads his flock to intrude on military funerals and proclaim, “God hates fags.” (Oh, the pain of even typing such stuff!) In a 2011 ruling related to this group’s hateful speech, Chief Justice John Roberts said, “Speech is powerful. It can stir people to action, move them to tears of both joy and sorrow, and—as it did here—inflict great pain.” Yes, the words we select are critical, and though citizens of the United States—Phelps included—are free to choose any words we wish, the impact of those words on our ways of thinking and being and doing deserves close inspection.
What difference does it make to think or talk about preaching as sermon communication? Does my use of that term annoy or concern you? Perhaps you are intrigued. Having had this conversation with hundreds of pastors during interactive workshops over the past several years, I am aware that curiosity is a less common initial reaction than disagreement or consternation.
A pastor who had heard only the title of my recent talk “Transforming Sermon Communication” wrote to me just last week to set me straight: “Preaching is not the same as communication. It is more holy, led by God. Studying communication techniques would diminish the movement of the Holy Spirit.” In other cases, clergy have raised their hands to speak, working carefully to correct my usage of the term. “Don’t you mean to say that though we are communicating when we are preaching, we are doing something more than that?” or “In fact, preaching is really completely different from other forms of communication, wouldn’t you say?”
Another incredibly common reaction when pastors hear the word communication in close proximity to the words sermon or preach goes something like this: “But only a few preachers still use emotional manipulation to get people out of the pews and down to the altar.” The underlying assumption of these initial responses seems to be that connecting the concept communication with the word sermon somehow degrades preaching. Dozens of pastors have shared various versions of seminary preaching-class stories in which the “communication” component of the process was set aside, noted as tangential to textual analysis or even declared unworthy of consideration for preachers-to-be.
In contrast, as I look through the lens of the communication scholar, this way of describing the sermon or homily elevates expectations for what will happen as a result of the sermon. A communication perspective on preaching brings together the pastor’s analysis of the text and the listeners’ responses. Because preaching has often been taught as if the text and the listener are separate, I purposefully use the cumbersome term sermon communication to lead preachers and listeners to a different way of thinking about this sacred experience.
By incorporating the idea of communication, I seek to help capture the essence of preaching at its best: people in relationship with one another and with God, speaking and listening for the purpose of spiritual transformation. I intend for this sermon communication paradigm to pull clergy toward a heightened awareness of critical realities in preaching: the spiritual growth purpose, the struggle to make meaning from spoken words, the concept of community, the profound responsibilities of speaker and listeners, and in light of all that—our tremendous gratitude for the Holy Spirit’s participation in the process.
This article is adapted and excerpted from Preaching That Matters: Reflective Practices for Transforming Sermons by Lori J. Carrell. Copyright © 2012 by the Alban Institute. All rights reserved.
This week – Featured Resources 30% off
Member discounts do not apply | Discount taken in shopping cart
ONLINE ORDERS ONLY | Valid through June 2, 2013
Preaching That Matters: Reflective Practices for Transforming Sermons
by Lori J. Carrell
“Listeners do love their pastors and they agree with the sermon content they hear,” Lori Carrell once explained to a group of pastors, “but most sermons don’t ask for change, and most listeners don’t experience spiritual growth as a result of the sermon.” A participant responded: “Let’s get practical. What changes are worth making, and how do I make them?” In Preaching that Matters, Lori Carrell shares answers to that question, drawing on the experiences of thousands of people—preachers and their listeners—whose effort she has studied over many years. In each chapter of this book, she offers research revelations about high impact preaching that will encourage and challenge readers to continue to grow as preachers.
Features include an interactive Google+ site, downloadable resources, and practical, helpful way to help preachers reflect on the impact of their sermons.
When God Speaks through You: How Faith Convictions Shape Preaching and Mission
by Craig A. Satterlee
Craig Satterlee helps congregations learn to articulate their convictions about the Christian faith and share them in a nonthreatening manner. This prepares them for broader conversation about how people’s faith convictions shape both their lives and the congregation’s worship, life together, and mission .
The Competent Pastor: Skills and Self-Knowledge for Serving Well
by Ronald D. Sisk
Competence, defined by Ron Sisk as “the ability to do what needs to be done,” requires ministers to understand themselves and others and to keep a realistic perspective on their lives. In The Competent Pastor, Sisk draws on the wisdom he gained in his many years as a pastor and seminary professor to describe what it takes to excel at negotiating the ins and outs of daily pastoral life.
Humble Leadership: Being Radically Open to God’s Guidance and Grace
by N. Graham Standish
Humble leadership, grounded in the teachings of Jesus, means recognizing that what we have and who we are are gifts from God, and our lives should reflect our gratitude for these gifts. It requires us to be radically and creatively open to God’s guidance, grace, and presence in everything. When we lead out of such openness, God’s power and grace flow through us.
Begin Fall with a new perspective on your congregation and your own leadership:
Break through the “150-in-worship”ceiling
Raising the Roof: The Pastoral-to-Program Size Transition in Congregations
July 16 – 17, 2013, Leader: Sarai Rice, Alban consultant
Doubletree Airport Hotel, Cincinnati, OH
Give up perpetual “problem-solving” for a whole new approach to leadership
Leading Adaptive Change
July 23-25, 2013, Leader: Susan Beaumont, Alban senior consultant and author
Simpsonwood Conference and Retreat Center, Atlanta, GA
Get a handle on stomach-churning situations with this classic “conflict 101”
Dealing with Congregational Discord
July 30 – August 1, 2013, Leader: Susan Nienaber, Alban senior consultant
Roslyn Retreat Center, Richmond, VA
Copyright © 2013 the Alban Institute. All rights reserved. We encourage you to share articles from the Alban Weekly with your congregation. We gladly allow permission to reprint articles from the Alban Weekly for one-time use by congregations and their leaders when the material is offered free of charge. All we ask is that you write to us at email@example.com and let us know how the Alban Weekly is making an impact in your congregation. If you would like to use any other Alban material, or if your intended use of the Alban Weekly does not fall within this scope, please complete our reprint permission request form .
Subscribe to the Alban Weekly.
Archive of past issues of the Alban Weekly.